zz-novelzz-novelStart free →
🤖 This story was generated by AI using zz-novel
AI score 6.0Mystery✓ Commercial License

The Scone in the Reading Nook

“On the day Maggie Pruitt reopens her aunt’s bookshop café, a poisoned scone makes her the prime suspect—and the village’s cleverest cat may hold the key.”

“On the day Maggie Pruitt reopens her aunt’s bookshop café, a poisoned scone makes her the prime suspect—and the village’s cleverest cat may hold the key.”

Font

Chapter 1

Opening Day

The bell above the door gave a sharp jangle, and Gideon Pike stepped into the bookshop café before Maggie had finished turning the sign to OPEN.

“You’ve got until Friday,” he said, shedding his expensive coat onto the nearest chair. “Then we discuss the offer properly.”

Maggie’s hand stayed on the sign. Flour dusted one sleeve of her blue cardigan; the other was already smudged with the black ink of the price labels. “Good morning to you too, Gideon.”

“Don’t start with the pleasantries.” His red face shone in the bright front window. “You’re sitting on a valuable property.”

“It’s a bookshop. I’m trying to sell books.”

“Then you’re already behind.”

Tamsin leaned against the counter, phone angled at him. “Should I film the bit where you pretend this is your shop?”

Gideon glared. “Put that away.”

“Make me.”

“Tamsin,” Maggie said, quietly.

Her niece lowered the phone, though her expression suggested the footage lived on somewhere. At sixteen, she had perfected the art of looking bored while taking in every detail.

Gideon tapped the counter with one thick finger. “You’ve reopened, fine. But sentiment doesn’t pay rates. I’ll come back when you’ve had a week to think.”

“Try not to trip over the books on your way out,” Maggie said.

He gave her a thin smile and left. The doorbell jingled behind him.

Bertie Nancarrow, setting out teaspoons at a table near the window, watched the door settle. “An invigorating start. One point to Maggie for the reply, though the round is still in progress.”

“Is it?” Maggie asked.

“Everything is, until the final question.”

A gray-and-white cat sat on the counter beside the till, amber eyes fixed on the empty doorway. Pippin’s clipped ear twitched. Then he turned his attention to a tray of scones.

“No,” Maggie told him. “Those are for paying customers.”

Pippin blinked once, slow and unconvinced.

The shop had belonged to Maggie’s aunt, and the little café at the back had been her favorite corner of it. Maggie had spent the last months sorting the books, repainting the café chairs, and trying not to compare every decision with the ones her aunt would have made. Today, the front door was open, the kettle was on, and the first customers were already nosing through the shelves.

It was more than she’d managed to promise herself.

The first rush brought wet coats, warm mugs, and a debate over whether the village history section should include a pamphlet about the 1978 crab shortage. Bertie moved between tables with a tray, greeting everyone as if he’d arranged the reopening and was kindly allowing Maggie to take credit.

Tamsin handled the till. Pippin supervised from the counter, making no effort to hide his disdain for a toddler who reached toward his tail.

“Your aunt knew what she was doing,” Bertie said, as he set a cup beside Maggie’s elbow. “People have missed this place.”

Maggie glanced toward the shelves. “I hope they remember the books, not just her lemon cake.”

“They remember both. A rare double feature.”

A woman in a bright scarf came through the door carrying a paper parcel. Celia Trevithick’s silver bob was immaculate despite the breeze, and she was already arranging a stack of napkins by the time she reached the counter.

“Look at you, Maggie. Open at last!” she said. “I’ve brought the spare sugar you asked for. The café always runs out just when the village decides it needs three cups of tea each.”

“I didn’t ask for sugar,” Maggie said.

“Your aunt did, months ago. I had some set aside.” Celia slid a small tin under the counter. “And don’t worry about the napkins. They were crooked.”

Pippin jumped down from the counter and disappeared beneath the nearest table.

“Still particular,” Celia said with a laugh. “He never did take to me.”

“Pippin has strong opinions about most people,” Tamsin said.

“Then he and I have something in common.” Celia straightened the napkins again, though they were already square. Her smile stayed in place as another customer called her name. “You’ll want me later. I’m excellent at tidying.”

She moved off before Maggie could answer.

The morning carried on. Maggie served tea, found a missing poetry book beneath a chair, and fielded two questions about whether the scones were homemade. By noon, a short queue had formed beside the counter.

Then Tamsin stopped with a mug in her hand.

“Where’s Pike?”

Maggie looked toward the reading nook. A broad shoulder showed between the high-backed chair and the bookcase. Gideon sat slumped beside a small plate, his head tipped at an awkward angle.

For one beat, Maggie waited for him to lift it and complain about the tea.

He didn’t.

She set down the towel. “Bertie.”

Bertie was already moving. “Tamsin, keep everyone back. Maggie, come with me.”

They reached the nook. Gideon’s face had gone slack, his eyes half-closed. One hand rested on the arm of the chair. Beside him sat a scone with a bite missing.

Maggie’s fingers hovered over his shoulder, then stopped short. “Gideon? Can you hear me?”

Bertie checked for a pulse at his neck. He held still for several seconds, then drew back.

“Call an ambulance,” he said to Tamsin. “And the police.”

Tamsin had her phone out already. “Calling both.”

Maggie stared at the plate. The scone looked ordinary, golden at the edges, with a dab of jam smeared beside it. The smell of butter and tea filled the nook. Her own hands had carried plates out all morning.

A customer whispered from behind her. “He was just threatening her.”

“I heard him say she had until Friday,” another answered.

Maggie turned. “He was alive when he came in. Plenty of people heard that.”

No one replied. Their eyes slid from her to the plate.

Bertie moved the other customers into the front of the shop, asking them to stay put until help arrived. His voice stayed calm; his hand closed around the back of a chair until his knuckles paled.

Maggie couldn’t make herself look away from Gideon. The polished shine of his coat sleeve caught the light. A crumb rested on the carpet by his shoe.

Tamsin lowered her phone. “They’re on their way.”

“Good.” Maggie rubbed her palms on her apron. Flour streaked the fabric, and her fingers wouldn’t stop trembling. “Nobody touches anything.”

“That includes you,” Bertie said, gentle but firm.

“I know.”

“Stay in the front, then. Let the police take the nook.”

Maggie backed away. Her heel struck the edge of the rug, and she caught herself on the bookcase. The spines pressed into her palm. From the counter, Pippin stared toward the nook, his tail tucked close around his paws.

Celia appeared in the doorway from the café. She had a folded dishcloth in her hands. “What’s happened?”

“Gideon,” Bertie said. “Don’t go near him.”

Celia’s smile vanished. “Oh. Oh, dear.” She looked at Maggie. “You’ve had a dreadful opening.”

Maggie could only nod.

The siren reached the village a few minutes later. The ambulance crew went straight to the reading nook. Then two uniformed officers arrived, and Bertie met them at the door.

One officer asked everyone to remain in the shop. The other spoke to Maggie by the counter.

“You prepared the food served today?”

“Yes. I baked the scones this morning.”

“Did Mr. Pike eat one?”

“There was one on the plate beside him.”

“Did you bring it to him?”

Maggie looked past the officer at the nook. The officer’s notebook was open. “I can’t remember. There were a lot of customers.”

“You can’t remember carrying it?”

“I carried plates out. I didn’t keep a list.”

Tamsin stood a few feet away, arms folded tight. “She was working. I was on the till.”

The officer glanced at her. “We’ll speak to everyone.”

Bertie returned from the nook carrying nothing. “The ambulance crew have confirmed he’s dead.”

The words made Maggie’s knees dip. She braced herself against the counter.

“Did they say what happened?” she asked.

“They’ll need the coroner. For now, the plate and the scone are being treated as evidence.”

One of the officers stepped back into the nook to photograph the table. “Nobody leaves until we’ve taken statements.”

The front door remained open, but nobody moved toward it. In the shop’s quiet, Maggie could hear the kettle clicking off behind the counter.

Bertie walked to the café table where Gideon had been sitting. He bent to look beneath the chair, then lifted a small slip of paper from the floor with a handkerchief.

“What is it?” Maggie asked.

“An order slip. It must have fallen from his pocket.” Bertie turned it toward the light. His brows drew together. “There’s a name written on it.”

The officer came over. “Let me see.”

Bertie didn’t hand it across. His blue eyes stayed on Maggie.

The slip bore the shop’s printed heading. Beneath it, in dark ink, were two words: Maggie Pruitt.

Chapter 2

A Cat’s Warning

“Let me see,” the officer said, holding out his hand for the slip.

Bertie kept it pinched in the handkerchief. “Of course. I’d rather not smudge it.”

Maggie stared at her name. The shop’s printed heading sat above it, neat and ordinary. The dark ink beneath looked anything but.

“That isn’t mine,” she said.

The officer’s pen paused. “You recognize the handwriting?”

“No. I recognize my name.”

Tamsin leaned closer, her arms still clamped around herself. “Could be a customer’s order.”

“Then why was it in Mr. Pike’s pocket?” the officer asked.

“Maybe he wanted to remember who he was threatening,” Tamsin said.

Maggie turned to her. “Threatening?”

Tamsin’s mouth tightened. She looked toward the front window, where a cluster of villagers had gathered outside, pretending not to watch. “I found something in the back room. I didn’t want to say it in front of them.”

The officer took the slip from Bertie, careful now to hold its edges. “We’ll discuss that after I’ve taken your statements.”

Tamsin dipped her chin. “Fine. But it wasn’t written by Aunt Hester, either.”

The officer gave her a warning look. Tamsin’s expression said she had noticed and was choosing not to care.

Maggie kept her hands flat on the counter. The police had taken the plate and scone. Gideon was still in the nook, hidden from view by the officer’s shoulder. Her name on that slip seemed to pull every eye in the shop toward her.

Bertie touched her sleeve. “One question at a time.”

“Starting with the one in Tamsin’s back room?”

“Precisely.”

The officer separated them for statements. Maggie answered the same questions in different words: when she had arrived, who had baked the scones, who had served them, whether Gideon had eaten one. Each answer scraped at the same blank patch in her memory. She had carried plates. She could not say which one had gone to the nook.

By the time the officer let her speak privately with Tamsin, the shop smelled of cooling tea and the sharp disinfectant an ambulance worker had used on the floor.

“What did you find?” Maggie asked.

Tamsin glanced at the officer, who was speaking to a customer near the door. Then she reached into the battered denim jacket and brought out a folded sheet of paper.

“I wasn’t snooping,” she said.

“That sounds promising.”

“It was sticking out from under the till. I was looking for the spare receipt roll.”

The paper bore Gideon Pike’s blocky handwriting. Maggie knew it from the notes he had left during his visits: hard strokes, as though even a pen had to do what he wanted.

She opened it.

The message was brief. He wanted the shop sold. He had already made a generous offer, and if Maggie insisted on refusing, he would make sure she understood what the village thought of people who stood in the way of progress. A line near the bottom had been underlined twice: We can settle this before opening day.

Maggie read it again, then folded the sheet along its old creases.

“He threatened you,” Tamsin said.

“He tried to make a business deal sound like a weather warning.”

“Still. The police find that with the slip and—”

“They haven’t found it. You did.”

“Not the distinction you want it to be.”

“No,” Maggie said. “It isn’t.”

Bertie had come within earshot. “May I?”

Maggie gave him the note. His eyes moved over the lines once. “Useful context. Not evidence that you killed him.”

“It gives them a reason to look at me.”

“It gives them a reason to look at Mr. Pike’s dealings,” Bertie replied. “And at anyone else he was pressuring.”

Tamsin tilted her head. “You say that like the village has a queue.”

“Mr. Pike was not famous for keeping his opinions to himself.”

The officer called Tamsin over to take her statement. She slid the note back into her jacket before going, keeping her gaze on Maggie until she reached the desk.

A flutter of movement drew Maggie toward the reading nook. Pippin had slipped from beneath the counter. His gray-and-white coat brushed the bookcase as he padded toward the narrow door to the storeroom.

“Pip,” Maggie murmured.

He did not look back. At the storeroom threshold, he stopped, ears angled forward, then turned sharply away.

Celia Trevithick stood just inside the shop entrance, her silver bob tidy beneath a bright green scarf. She had a stack of clean cups balanced in her arms.

“Awful business,” she said. “I brought these from home. The café will need them, and I can put the kettle on if you’re overwhelmed.”

Pippin’s tail gave one hard flick. He backed away from her, then threaded between Maggie’s ankles and vanished behind the counter.

“Thank you,” Maggie said. “The police have asked us not to move anything.”

“Of course, of course.” Celia set the cups on the nearest clear shelf. “You shouldn’t have to manage all this alone.”

Her eyes passed over Maggie’s face, then settled on the folded note in Bertie’s hand.

“What’s that?” she asked.

“Something Mr. Pike left behind,” Bertie said.

Celia’s smile remained, but her fingers stopped arranging the cups. “He did have a habit of leaving trouble behind him. I imagine Maggie has enough of that already.”

Maggie watched her hands. The scarf. The cups. Everything in Celia’s reach seemed to acquire an order.

“Have you been in the storeroom today?” Maggie asked.

Celia looked up. “Only to fetch a jar of cinnamon before the opening. Your aunt used to keep it in the pantry, didn’t she?”

The answer came quickly. Maggie could not recall telling Celia where anything had been kept.

“Yes,” she said. “She did.”

“I thought so.” Celia nudged the cups into a straighter stack. “I’ve always been good at remembering where people put things.”

Pippin reappeared on the other side of the counter. He fixed his amber eyes on Celia, then trotted to the low cupboard beside the worktop. His paw struck the door once. Then again.

“Not now,” Maggie said softly.

Pippin scratched at the cupboard seam.

Celia gave a light laugh. “He’s always had strong opinions about storage.”

“He’s usually got a reason,” Tamsin said. She had returned from her statement and was watching Celia instead of the cat.

Celia’s smile thinned at the edges. “Cats have very little to do all day.”

“Then he must be exceptionally committed.”

Bertie crouched beside the cupboard. “Does this hold the café spices?”

“Some of them,” Maggie said. “The rest are in the pantry.”

“Was the jar there on opening day?”

Maggie searched her memory: flour on her sleeves, the till sticking, customers calling for tea. “I don’t know. Celia brought cinnamon from the storeroom, she said.”

“I fetched the jar,” Celia corrected, still bright. “It was already in the pantry.”

“Right,” Maggie said. The correction was small, but Celia had made it before anyone accused her of anything.

Bertie stood. He did not touch the cupboard. “Let the officers decide what gets opened. They’ll want the scene undisturbed.”

The nearest officer glanced over at the word “scene.” Bertie lifted both hands, mild as a quizmaster facing a disputed answer.

“Just discussing storage.”

The officer returned to his notes.

Tamsin shifted closer to Maggie. “The note makes you look bad. The slip makes you look worse. We can’t leave it at that.”

Maggie looked at the plate being sealed in a clear evidence bag, then at the folded note. Gideon had wanted her shop badly enough to threaten her. Someone had wanted his silence badly enough to poison him. The two facts might be connected, but not in the way the village would decide before supper.

“You’re right,” she said.

Tamsin blinked. “I was expecting at least one auntly lecture.”

“Save it for a less crowded room.”

Maggie faced Bertie. “Help me sort out who had access to the scones, the cupboards, and Gideon’s business. Properly. No guessing.”

Bertie inclined his head. “We’ll start with a list and test each item against what we can establish.”

Celia lifted the cups again. “I’ll leave you to it, then. Do call if you need anything.”

Pippin backed away as she passed. He kept his eyes on her until the door shut behind her.

“Your cat has just made a witness statement,” Tamsin said.

“He has,” Bertie replied, “but we still need to know what he saw.”

Maggie crouched beside the cupboard. Pippin had left a light print in the dust on the floor, ending at the door’s lower edge. She followed it with her eyes, careful not to touch the wood.

A smear of blue sugar dust marked the cupboard latch.

Chapter 3

The Quizmaster’s Questions

Bertie stopped Maggie from touching the blue smear.

“Leave it where it is,” he said. “The officers will want to see it.”

Maggie drew her hand back. Pippin sat by the cupboard, one paw lifted, his amber eyes fixed on the latch.

Tamsin angled her phone toward the mark, then hesitated. “Photo?”

“Ask the officer first,” Bertie said. “We’ve had quite enough of people deciding what evidence means before it’s been examined.”

The officer nearest the counter gave a small nod. Tamsin took a picture without touching the cupboard.

Bertie studied the latch from a step away. Blue sugar dust, perhaps. The café kept colored sugar for decorating cakes, though he could not remember seeing that shade in the kitchen. A clue, certainly. A conclusion, not yet.

“Where were the scones before they went out?” he asked Maggie.

“In the kitchen. I baked them this morning. They cooled on the rack, then I put them on the plate.” She pointed toward the evidence bag. “I didn’t leave them unattended for long.”

“Long is a slippery measure,” Tamsin said.

“Not helpful, but accurate,” Bertie replied. “Who had access to the kitchen?”

“Maggie, me, and Celia,” Tamsin said. “And anyone else who wandered in.”

Maggie pressed her floury hands together. “Celia brought cups in and out. She was helping.”

“Helpful people can still be useful witnesses,” Bertie said. “We’ll write down what each person remembers, then see where the accounts agree.”

He took out his notebook. A list was preferable to a theory. The village had already supplied several theories, each delivered with the confidence of a pub quiz answer shouted before the question was finished.

The officer said they could speak to anyone who had been in the café before opening, provided they did not disturb the kitchen or the evidence. Bertie asked Maggie for the names of the first arrivals.

She gave him a short list: herself, Tamsin, Celia, the delivery driver, and Gideon.

“Gideon arrived before you opened?” Bertie asked.

“After I’d put the sign out. He came in, complained about the price of tea, and sat in the nook.” Maggie’s mouth tightened. “He had his own coat over the chair. I was at the counter.”

That placed him in the shop, but it did not explain the poison. Bertie wrote the time as approximate.

Tamsin leaned over the notebook. “There’s also the delivery book. The driver signed in.”

“Good. We should check it.”

The book lay beneath the till, where Maggie kept invoices and supplier notes. Bertie asked the officer before retrieving it. Once permission was given, Maggie opened to the morning’s page and held it so he could read without taking it from her.

The delivery boy’s signature was rushed and mostly illegible. Beside it, someone had written a time: 7:18. A second entry, in a different hand, read: “Mr Vale—early call.”

“Vale?” Tamsin said. “That’s Gideon’s business rival, isn’t it?”

Maggie looked at the line again. “Edwin Vale. He wanted the old net loft by the harbor. Gideon had been after it too.”

“Did he come into the shop?” Bertie asked.

“He came to the door,” Maggie said. “I was unpacking the tea delivery. He asked if Gideon was here. I told him I hadn’t seen him.”

“Was that before Gideon arrived?”

“I think so.”

Bertie made a note, adding the uncertainty. A rival seeking Gideon was worth checking. It was also the sort of detail that would race through Port Wren and turn into a motive before anyone had confirmed a time.

Tamsin’s phone was already in her hand. “If Vale wanted the net loft, and Gideon was in his way—”

“Then we ask what happened,” Bertie said. “We don’t write the ending first.”

She lowered the phone, though her thumb hovered over the screen.

Maggie looked toward the front window. “People will hear he was here and decide that’s enough.”

“They may,” Bertie said. “That is why the timing matters. If the scone was tampered with before the café opened, someone could have reached it before Gideon sat down.”

“Or after,” Tamsin said.

“Possibly. But we can narrow the opportunity by establishing where the food was and who could reach it.”

He asked Maggie to describe the morning in order, then checked each point against the delivery record and the recollections they could gather. The scones had come out of the oven before seven. Maggie had set them on the kitchen rack to cool. She had moved them to a plate once the glaze was ready. The plate stayed in the kitchen until she carried it to the counter shortly before opening.

“Was the cupboard opened while the scones were cooling?” Bertie asked.

“I don’t remember,” Maggie said. “I was measuring tea and finding the café keys. Celia was in and out.”

Tamsin frowned at the word “in.” “You said she brought cups.”

“Cups, napkins, a jug. She offered to help with everything.”

Bertie wrote that down too. The blue dust on the latch might be connected to the sugar, but they needed to know whether it had been there before the morning’s preparations. He would not turn Pippin’s paw at the cupboard into proof of anything. The cat had pointed them toward the place. The humans had to do the rest.

“Let’s speak to the delivery boy,” he said. “He may remember who arrived first.”

The officer agreed to fetch him from outside. A few minutes later, a young man in a waterproof jacket came in, rubbing his hands together. He glanced at the sealed plate and then at the notebook.

Bertie gave him his name and asked him to describe his visit without prompting.

“Just the usual crates,” the boy said. “I dropped the tea and milk at the back. Signed the book. There was a woman already there, though.”

“Can you describe her?” Bertie asked.

“Silver hair. Bright scarf. She was carrying a stack of cups through to the kitchen.” He looked toward Maggie, unsure. “Celia, wasn’t it?”

Maggie kept her hands still on the counter. “Yes. She was helping.”

The boy nodded. “She got there before me, actually. I remember because the back door was open when I came round, and she was already inside.”

Tamsin stopped tapping her phone.

Bertie glanced at his note, then back at the delivery boy. “You’re certain it was before you unloaded?”

“Yeah. She came through the kitchen while I was setting the crates down.” He hesitated. “I thought she worked there.”

“She doesn’t,” Maggie said.

The boy’s gaze dropped to his shoes. “Right. Sorry. I just saw her going in.”

Bertie closed his notebook, careful not to let the snap of it sound like a verdict. “Thank you. That gives us a time to check. Nothing more until it’s checked.”

The officer guided the delivery boy away to speak with him separately. Bertie watched the back door, then the cupboard latch, where the blue smear remained untouched.

Maggie’s voice came low. “Celia was in the kitchen before anyone else.”

“Before the delivery,” Bertie corrected gently. “We still need the exact time, and we need to know what she did.”

Tamsin’s eyes had fixed on the sealed scone. “And whether she had time to do something to it.”

Bertie opened his notebook again. On the page, beneath Vale’s name, he wrote Celia’s—then drew a line under both.

The first question had been who could reach the scone. Now there were two names, and one of them had been inside the kitchen before the first delivery arrived.

📖

Unlock the rest of this story

Create a free account to read all remaining chapters.

✓Unlock all remaining chapters instantly
✓Save stories to your library
✓Export as PDF or TXT
Sign Up Free & Continue Reading →Already have an account? Sign In

Free plan · No credit card required.

Share this story

Post on XShare on Reddit

More stories from the community

Browse Discover →

Want your own personalized story?

Start writing for free →

Subscribe to our Newsletter

Monthly story picks · New features · Writing inspiration, straight to your inbox

No spam, unsubscribe anytime