“Two rivals, one solo, and a melody neither can finish alone.”
“Two rivals, one solo, and a melody neither can finish alone.”
Chapter 1
The room assignment was clipped to a board outside the festival office, and Adrian Mercer read it twice before accepting that the ink would not rearrange itself.
Room Four: Adrian Mercer, Bennett Shaw. Afternoon session.
“That’s a mistake,” he said.
Marina Cole checked the page on her clipboard. Silver hair, straight posture, no wasted movement. “It isn’t.”
“They’ve assigned us the same room for the entire session?”
“Yes.”
Bennett appeared behind him, violin case hanging from one hand. “Looks like we’re neighbors.”
Adrian turned. Bennett’s auburn hair had fallen across his forehead, and his sleeves were rolled up despite the cool breeze coming off the lake. He looked far too pleased with the notice.
“Temporarily,” Adrian said.
“For the entire session,” Marina corrected. “The rooms are booked. You’ll share this one.”
Bennett leaned past Adrian to inspect the page. “I’ve had worse arrangements.”
“Have you?”
“Once. A quartet rehearsal in a room with a piano that played whenever someone leaned on the wall.”
“That’s not an arrangement. That’s a maintenance issue.”
Bennett laughed. Adrian disliked how easily the sound filled the corridor.
Marina tapped the clipboard against her palm. “You’re both here for the same reason. The closing concert has one featured solo. I’ll choose the musician after a blind audition.”
The words changed the air. Adrian had known the solo would be competitive. Hearing it stated beside Bennett’s name made the stakes feel less like a line on a festival schedule and more like a door with one key.
Bennett’s amusement thinned. “One solo?”
“One.” Marina’s gaze moved between them. “You’ll each have the same audition conditions. The panel won’t see the performers. Preparation is your responsibility.”
Adrian adjusted his grip on his case. “When will the audition take place?”
“The schedule will be posted this week. Until then, you have the rooms assigned to you. Use them well.”
Bennett lifted his case. “We will.”
Adrian glanced at him. “You speak for both of us now?”
“I’m being optimistic.”
“Try being accurate.”
Marina’s expression didn’t change. “Save the competition for the music.”
She handed them the key. Bennett took it first, then held the door for Adrian with a theatrical sweep of his arm.
“After you, Mercer.”
Adrian went in without thanking him.
Room Four was narrow, with two music stands, a piano pushed against one wall, and a window that looked toward the lake. The afternoon light caught the varnish on Adrian’s old violin case. The room smelled of rosin and warm wood. A second case rested on the chair near the window; Bennett had apparently arrived before them.
Adrian set his own case beside the other chair.
Bennett looked at the two stands. “A generous amount of space.”
“It’s a practice room, not a ballroom.”
“Good. I’d hate to waste the floor.”
Adrian opened his case and checked the instrument. His left index finger’s callus pressed against the violin’s neck as he tested the strings. The familiar resistance steadied him. A room could be shared. The audition would still be his to win.
Bennett took his violin out and set the shoulder rest in place. “What are you working on?”
“My repertoire.”
“Specific.”
“You asked a broad question.”
“I was trying to make conversation.”
“Then you should ask something you actually want to know.”
Bennett considered that, then lowered his bow. “What do you want to play at the closing concert?”
“The solo.”
“Of course.”
The answer was too quick, too easy. Adrian tightened the bow hair by a fraction. “And you?”
“The solo.”
“Then we’re clear.”
Bennett smiled. “We are. That’s almost friendly.”
“It was a statement of fact.”
“Your facts have excellent posture.”
Adrian looked at him. “Your jokes need work.”
“Good thing the session is long.”
The session. Weeks of shared rooms, overlapping schedules, and Bennett’s easy confidence taking up every available inch. Adrian had come to the festival to prove that years of disciplined practice could carry him to a stage no one could mistake. A rival was useful. A rival in the same room was an inconvenience with a violin case.
Outside, someone crossed the path toward the dormitories, carrying a cello. A few notes drifted from another building, then stopped.
Marina’s voice came from the doorway. “One more thing.”
They both turned.
“The closing program is tight, but it isn’t fixed down to the last note. If either of you has a proposal that serves the concert, bring it to me. It needs my approval.”
Bennett glanced at Adrian, but said nothing.
Adrian asked, “The solo remains one position?”
“Yes. The audition decides that.” Marina checked something on her clipboard. “The program has room for other choices, if they earn their place.”
She left them with the door open and the key on the piano.
Bennett picked up the key and set it on the windowsill between their cases. “Well. One solo, one room, six weeks.”
“The room is for this session,” Adrian said.
“And the session repeats.”
“That doesn’t make it ours.”
“No. It makes it shared.”
Adrian wanted to tell him that shared was not the same as equal. Instead, he took his violin to the stand nearest the door and set his music in place. He could spend the afternoon resenting the room or use it. The answer was obvious, even if Bennett wasn’t.
He drew the bow across an open string, then began a scale at a measured tempo. The first notes came out clean. He moved up the instrument, keeping each shift controlled and each pitch centered. The sound filled the small room without asking permission.
Bennett waited several measures, then began his own scale by the window.
His tempo was quicker. His tone had more edge, less polish in the transitions. He didn’t follow Adrian’s pattern. He chose another key, another direction, another way to occupy the room.
Their scales met at the wall between them, distinct lines pressing through the thin plaster.
Adrian kept playing. If Bennett meant the room as a challenge, Adrian would answer with every note.
Chapter 2
The last note of Adrian’s scale thinned against the room’s narrow walls. Bennett finished a measure later, then ran the phrase again with a different turn at the end.
Adrian lowered his bow. “If we’re going to practice at the same time, we need some agreement about volume.”
“Your scale was loud enough to make one.”
“That was the point.”
“Then it worked.” Bennett rested his violin against his shoulder. “You’ve got the room this afternoon too, don’t you?”
“I don’t know. The assignment was for yesterday’s session.”
“Right. So we settle it today.”
Adrian set his violin down on the stand. The room was barely wide enough for two people and their cases. A full day of improvisation would be a waste. “I practice mornings. I need at least three uninterrupted hours.”
“So do I.”
“Then we have a problem.”
“We have a room with two stands.” Bennett tilted his head toward the windowsill, where the key lay between their cases. “And two people who are apparently expected to use it.”
Adrian had no interest in negotiating every day. “How many hours do you need?”
“Depends on the day.”
“That isn’t a number.”
“Fine. Two hours. Sometimes three.”
“Then we split the day.”
Bennett considered it. “You want mornings?”
“I said I practice mornings.”
“And I said I need them too.”
The irritation came easily. Adrian had spent enough years arranging his life around practice to resent having to bargain for it. “I’m not asking you to stop playing. I’m asking for defined hours.”
“Good. Because I wasn’t planning to stop.”
Bennett pulled a folded festival schedule from his case and set it on the piano. The page had already been marked in several places. He borrowed a pencil from the ledge and drew a line down the empty margin.
“Your mornings,” he said. “My afternoons.”
“That gives you more room.”
“You said three hours. I’m giving you three.”
“And your practice?”
“I’ll take what’s left.”
“That isn’t a schedule. It’s a favor.”
“Then don’t call it one.”
Adrian studied the page. Bennett had left the evening blank. “What about the rest of the week?”
“We write it down. We can swap days if a lesson or rehearsal comes up.”
“You want to renegotiate whenever it’s convenient?”
“I want us to have a schedule that works when the festival changes its schedule.” Bennett tapped the pencil against the paper. “Unless you’d prefer a strict rule that makes no sense by Thursday.”
The answer was sensible, which made it annoying. Adrian took the pencil. “Three hours each, where possible. No playing through the other person’s block.”
“Unless we both agree.”
“Fine.”
“And we write swaps in the margin.”
Adrian added the terms beneath Bennett’s line. His handwriting was neat; Bennett’s notes crowded the edges and ran downhill. Together, they blocked out the next several days, with Adrian’s mornings and Bennett’s afternoons. The evenings stayed open.
At the bottom, Adrian wrote their names beside their respective hours.
“Initial it,” he said.
Bennett signed first, pressing hard enough to leave a mark on the sheet below. “There. A document.”
“It’s a piece of paper.”
“A piece of paper with your approval. Very official.”
Adrian added his initials. “If you change a time, write it down.”
“I heard you the first time.”
“Good.”
They put the schedule on the piano, where neither could miss it. The room’s silence felt different now: less like a contest waiting to happen, more like a timer. Adrian could work with a timer.
He opened the case beside the chair and checked the bridge, the strings, the familiar fittings. The old case had a scrape along one side that had been there for years. Nothing about it needed changing. His preparation did.
The featured solo was still undecided. A blind audition meant no one could rely on a name or a reputation. Only the playing counted. Adrian wanted that chance. He had wanted it since Marina Cole had described the concert, and sharing a room with Bennett did not make the goal less important.
He drew out his violin and set the music on the stand nearest the door.
Bennett glanced at the page. “You’re starting?”
“I didn’t come here to negotiate.”
“Could’ve fooled me.”
Adrian began with the passage that had troubled him the day before. The first attempt was clean until the shift, where the note arrived a fraction sharp. He stopped, adjusted the fingering, and tried again.
Bennett started a passage of his own by the window. He played with energy, shaping the line as if it had somewhere urgent to go. Adrian kept his focus on the printed notes, but the sound found its way in anyway. The phrasing was bold. It also made the room difficult to ignore.
Adrian went back to the shift. This time the note settled where it belonged.
He continued into the next phrase, listening for the place where the line could open without losing its shape. Bennett’s playing stopped. A short silence followed.
“Again,” Bennett said.
Adrian did not break off. “I’m aware.”
“No, I mean the phrase. The second one.”
“Why?”
“Your first ending sounded like you were afraid of it.”
That was a nerve he had not meant to expose. “I’m not afraid of anything in the passage.”
“Then play it like you believe that.”
Adrian restarted. He let the phrase travel further before bringing it back, still controlled, but no longer clipped short. Bennett’s instrument joined after a moment, not in unison but in a separate line. Adrian’s concentration narrowed to the notes, the pulse, the way their sounds occupied opposite sides of the room.
He finished the phrase.
“Better,” Bennett said.
“You don’t have to comment.”
“I know.”
Adrian turned a page. “And you don’t have to stop every time I get something right.”
“Wasn’t planning to.”
Bennett resumed his own passage. Adrian followed with the next section, and soon they were both working, each taking the other’s sound as a fact of the room. The measures came around again and again. Adrian corrected one shift, then another. Bennett pushed his tempo too fast and had to bring it back. Neither asked the other to stop.
When Adrian’s block ended, he set down his bow. His annoyance had not disappeared. It had become manageable, contained by the written hours and the work waiting in front of him. He could practice beside Bennett. He could even learn something from it.
Bennett lifted the schedule from the piano and made one small mark in the blank evening column.
“What’s that?” Adrian asked.
“Nothing yet.” Bennett put the page back. “We’ll see what the week needs.”
Adrian packed his violin away. The phrase Bennett had been playing started again, then faltered near its end. He left it unfinished.
“I’ll be back tomorrow morning,” Adrian said.
“Your time’s on the page.”
Outside, the lake caught the pale morning light between the buildings. Adrian headed toward it, and Bennett’s unfinished phrase followed him out toward the lake.
Chapter 3
By the second week, the blank evening column on their schedule had become a shared rehearsal slot.
At seven, Adrian found Bennett in the practice room with the schedule pinned beside the door and a stack of music on the piano.
“You’re early,” Bennett said.
“It’s seven.”
“Then I’ve been waiting exactly as long as the schedule allows.”
Adrian set his case down. “A stirring sacrifice.”
Bennett tapped the pages. “Before we start, there’s something I want you to look at.”
The top sheet was covered in pencil marks: slurs, rests, dynamic changes, whole measures crossed out and rewritten. Adrian recognized the unfinished phrase Bennett had been playing on their first morning together.
“This is yours?”
“I’ve been reworking a violin duet for a couple of weeks.” Bennett’s usual humor had dropped away. “I didn’t know if I’d show you. I still don’t know if it works.”
Adrian looked from the page to him. “You brought it to rehearsal.”
“Apparently I made a decision.”
The arrangement was written for two violins. It wasn’t a solo with a second part tucked underneath; the lines answered and interrupted each other, trading the melody before it could settle. Bennett had marked one passage with a long, loose phrase, then set a clean run of even notes opposite it.
“You’re putting your phrasing against mine,” Adrian said.
“I’m trying to.” Bennett leaned against the piano. “You make a line hold together. I make it breathe. There should be a way to do both without one of us getting dragged along.”
The care in the pages gave Adrian pause. The revisions weren’t a quick exercise. Bennett had spent hours shaping each part, then made room for Adrian’s habits without sanding them down.
“Why show me now?”
“Because that phrase kept bothering me. And because you’ll tell me if it’s bad.”
“I can tell you that without playing it.”
“Then you’ll have to be efficient.”
Adrian turned to the first page. “Which part do you want?”
“Take the upper line. I’ll follow.”
“Is that the arrangement’s instruction or yours?”
“Mine. For now.”
Adrian fitted his violin under his chin and set the page on the stand. Bennett picked up his own instrument. The room’s familiar sharp smell of rosin clung to the warm air.
They began.
The first passage went cleanly enough. Adrian kept the pulse steady while Bennett let the melody stretch. At the next entrance, the lines crossed, and Bennett’s phrase arrived a fraction late.
They stopped.
“You’re waiting for me,” Adrian said.
“I’m listening.”
“You can do both. Try entering on the beat.”
“That defeats the point of the phrase.”
“Then mark the beat more clearly.”
Bennett glanced at the score. “You really do think every problem can be solved by putting a line under it.”
“Most of them.”
They tried again. This time Bennett entered on the beat, then let the line widen after the first measure. Adrian held the pulse without flattening the melody. The music moved forward, but neither part gave up its character.
At the end of the page, Adrian lowered his bow. “That works.”
Bennett studied the next measure. “You sound surprised.”
“I’m careful with praise.”
“Good. I’d hate to lose the mystery.”
Adrian looked over the marked pages again. Bennett had penciled an arrow above the next section. The lead passed from one violin to the other, then returned in a variation Adrian would have chosen himself: precise, but not rigid.
“Here, you want me to take the melody,” Adrian said.
“I want you to decide when it’s yours.”
“That’s a convenient instruction.”
“It’s a duet. Convenient instructions are scarce.”
Bennett adjusted the music stand. One of its feet slid on the floor, tipping the pages toward them. Adrian reached across and placed his hand over Bennett’s on the loose clamp, holding the stand steady while Bennett tightened it.
He could have waited for Bennett to fix it alone. He could have grabbed the metal without touching him. Instead, Adrian kept his hand there until the stand held firm.
Bennett looked at him. “Thanks.”
“The page was about to fall.”
“It didn’t.”
Adrian took his hand away. “Then the clamp has earned its place.”
Bennett turned back to the music. He didn’t tease him for the gesture or make it into something larger. Adrian was grateful, and a little unsettled by the gratitude.
They resumed from the marked passage.
This time Bennett began with the melody. Adrian kept the lower line steady, listening for the small changes in Bennett’s timing. When the music shifted, Adrian took the lead without waiting for permission. Bennett followed, then answered with a phrase of his own.
The arrangement gave them room to make choices. Adrian could draw a line taut and clear; Bennett could loosen it without breaking the rhythm. Each had to notice when the other was ready to move.
They reached the last page. The final measure had been rewritten so often that the paper showed a faint smudge beneath the notes.
“You’ve changed this ending a lot,” Adrian said.
“It kept sounding like one of us was supposed to win.”
“And now?”
“Now it sounds like we might both get to finish.”
Adrian considered the phrase. The ending didn’t resolve with a flourish. It asked them to hold the last note together, neither carrying the other through it.
“Again,” he said.
Bennett set his bow. “From the top?”
“From the first measure.”
They played the arrangement once more. Adrian’s pulse gave Bennett’s phrasing somewhere to go; Bennett’s line kept Adrian from treating every measure like a test. When the melody passed between them, they let it pass. No one rushed to reclaim it.
The last note came. Adrian held his bow steady, matching Bennett’s sustained tone until they both released.
The room fell silent; the final shared note lingered between them.
Create a free account to read all remaining chapters.
Free plan · No credit card required.
Share this story
More stories from the community
Browse Discover →Want your own personalized story?
Start writing for free →Monthly story picks · New features · Writing inspiration, straight to your inbox
No spam, unsubscribe anytime