“A forged masterpiece, a crowded Exposition, and two inconveniently brilliant accomplices.”
“A forged masterpiece, a crowded Exposition, and two inconveniently brilliant accomplices.”
Chapter 1
Camille Duret saw the painting through the open gallery doors and forgot the rain.
It stood beneath a row of brass lamps, framed in gilt and surrounded by the sort of space usually reserved for royalty or a particularly expensive chandelier. A river blurred across the canvas in pale blue and silver. A line of poplars leaned into the wind. The light on the water was soft enough to persuade a tired eye and precise enough to fool a careless one.
Camille was neither tired nor careless.
She stopped on the threshold. Water ran from the hem of her green wool jacket to the polished floor.
A placard beneath the frame announced: CLAUDE MONET. MORNING ON THE SEINE. Private collection. Offered for purchase during the Universal Exposition.
Her painting. Or near enough to make her stomach tighten.
She had not seen it since it left her hands. She had imagined it in a dozen places: locked away, sold abroad, cut down for a smaller frame. Not here, in the Varenne Gallery, set out for Auguste Montferrand with a label that gave it a title she had never heard before.
Camille stepped closer.
The brushwork was convincing from the doorway. Up close, the river’s reflections had a stubborn regularity. The smallest strokes repeated where they should have varied. A clever eye might notice. A railroad baron’s eye, dazzled by the name, might not.
At the front of the room, Auguste Montferrand stood beside a table set with champagne. He was broad-shouldered in a cream suit, his silver moustache carefully groomed, an amber-capped walking stick resting in his hand. Odette Varenne stood with him in black silk and violet gloves, poised as if the gallery had been built around her.
A third man, tall and neat in a museum-black coat, was studying the painting’s frame. Sandy hair, wire spectacles, brass catalogue pencil behind one ear. He held a small notebook open but had not yet written in it.
Camille knew him by reputation: Étienne Ravel, registrar. The man who could make a wall of paperwork sound more final than a locked door.
She moved to the side of the painting, keeping the frame between herself and the room. Along its lower edge, something caught the lamplight: a fresh brass inventory nail, bright against the old wood.
That was wrong.
Her fingers found the narrow seam where the frame met the canvas. She pressed lightly, testing the fit. The nail had gone in recently. Whoever had fixed it there had been in a hurry or had wanted it noticed.
“Touching the merchandise is not part of the tour,” said a voice behind her.
Camille turned. Ravel had come up without a sound.
“Then your tour needs better merchandise,” she said.
His gaze moved from her wet sleeve to her hand beside the frame. “You were tampering with it.”
“I was looking.”
“Your fingers were looking.”
“Then they have better manners than most people here.”
He closed his notebook. “Your explanation?”
“Rain.”
“Rain does not usually approach a painting from the side.”
“Perhaps it has a more interesting life than you do.”
His expression barely changed, but something in his attention sharpened. “You know the work?”
Camille glanced toward Odette. The gallery owner was smiling at Auguste, describing the painting as if she had watched Monet make each stroke. Camille could hear none of the words over the gathering’s low talk.
“I know frames,” Camille said.
“And yet you were looking at the canvas.”
“I am versatile.”
“Are you an expert?”
“Not for free.”
“Convenient.”
“For me, yes.”
Ravel glanced at the fresh nail. “What did you see?”
“Nothing that concerns you.”
“Then why touch the frame?”
“Because it concerns me.”
“That is not an explanation.”
“It is the one you have.”
Auguste’s laugh carried across the room. Odette had raised a glass. The guests turned toward them, a modest audience assembled for an announcement.
Camille tried to step away. Ravel shifted with her, keeping the painting in view.
“Wait,” he said.
“Is that an order?”
“It is a request.”
“Then you should have made it before blocking my path.”
He moved half a step aside. The gesture was courteous. It also left no clear way out without passing him.
Camille leaned toward the frame again, as if she had only come to admire the gilding. “That nail is new.”
“I can see that.”
“Then you can see it does not belong.”
“Frames are repaired.”
“Not with a bright brass nail hammered through old gilding. Someone wanted the frame shut in a hurry.”
“Or someone had an imperfect workman.”
“Those are not mutually exclusive.”
Ravel’s eyes went to the edge of the canvas. “You think something is wrong with the painting.”
“I think the gallery has hung it under a name it may not deserve.”
“That is a serious accusation.”
“Not yet. It’s an observation.”
“Observations should be supported.”
“By whom? The man with the pencil?”
“By anyone who expects to be believed.”
Camille studied him. He spoke like a man who had never had to make a living from the gap between what people saw and what they wanted to see.
“Then you’ll want to look closely,” she said.
“I intend to.”
“Good. Stay close to the frame.”
His brows drew together. “Why?”
“Because it may try to run.”
She turned away before he could ask more.
Odette lifted her glass. “Monsieur Montferrand has kindly agreed to acquire this exceptional Monet as the jewel of his Exposition collection.”
A pleasant murmur moved through the room. Auguste bowed with the satisfaction of a man accepting applause at a station he had built himself.
“The purchase,” he announced, “will take place at the Exposition in three weeks. A proper destination for a work that deserves a proper public.”
Camille felt the gallery tilt. Three weeks. A public sale, an advertised name, a buyer whose money could make a lie look permanent.
Ravel had heard it too. He looked toward the placard, then at Odette, who was already receiving congratulations.
Auguste continued, “The Exposition brings the world to Paris. It seems only right that Paris should show the world what it can recognize.”
“Recognition is an unreliable witness,” Camille murmured.
Ravel looked at her. “You have an alternative?”
“Not yet.”
“Then we are both short of evidence.”
“We are not both short of anything.”
“Except an explanation.”
She gave him a cool look. “You may have one when you stop asking like a police inspector.”
“I am not a police inspector.”
“Then the costume is doing you no favors.”
Before he could reply, Odette approached. Her smile was warm enough for the guests and measured enough for Camille.
“Camille Duret,” she said. “You have brought the weather in with you.”
“I thought the gallery might need washing.”
“How industrious. Monsieur Ravel, may I present Mademoiselle Duret? She is an artist of sorts.”
“Of sorts?” Camille said. “You make even a compliment sound itemized.”
“I have found that precision saves time.”
Odette’s violet-gloved hand rested lightly on the back of a chair. She did not look at the painting. She did not need to.
“Are you acquainted with the work?” Ravel asked.
“I am acquainted with the room,” Odette said. “Camille has visited before.”
“Not this painting.”
“Have you?” Odette’s gaze met Camille’s. “I thought you had been busy.”
Camille felt the old trap snap shut: a question shaped so that any answer could be turned into evidence. She kept her voice light.
“I have been busy. It is a demanding city.”
Auguste joined them, carrying a glass of champagne. “And what does our visitor think of the prize?”
“Your Excellency,” Odette said, “Mademoiselle Duret is not here in any official capacity.”
“Good. Official capacities are always getting in the way of a useful opinion.” He looked at Camille. “Do you like it?”
“No.”
Odette’s smile did not fade. “Camille.”
“What? He asked.”
Auguste laughed. “At least the answer arrived on time. Why not?”
“The water is too even.”
“Too even for the Seine?” he asked.
“Too even for a painter who wanted you to think it was the Seine.”
The smile on Odette’s face remained perfectly composed. Ravel’s attention did not.
Auguste glanced back at the canvas. “You are an artist?”
“Among other inconveniences.”
“Can you tell a Monet from a clever imitation?”
“Sometimes.”
“Can you tell this one?”
“Not from here.”
Odette made a small, gracious sound. “She is being modest.”
“Modesty is best used sparingly,” Camille said. “It loses value when sold by the yard.”
Auguste enjoyed that. “Then let us have the honest answer. Is it genuine?”
Camille could not say yes. She could not say no without handing the room a confession that was not hers to make.
“I have not examined it properly,” she said.
“Then examine it properly,” Auguste replied.
Odette’s eyes stayed on Camille. “The painting has already been examined by people with considerably more experience.”
“People who did not notice the new nail?”
The words escaped before Camille could stop them.
Ravel turned toward the frame. “The nail?”
“There is a fresh brass inventory nail at the lower edge,” she said. “It is new enough to shine. The rest of the fittings are old.”
Auguste set down his glass. “Is that significant?”
“It may be nothing,” Ravel said, approaching the painting. “A replacement fitting would not establish anything about the work.”
“It establishes that somebody has handled the frame recently,” Camille said.
“That is not unusual.”
“Then why not use a nail that matches?”
Odette answered before he could. “A workman’s judgment, perhaps. We have had several deliveries this week. It would be tedious to assign a conspiracy to every bright piece of metal.”
“Agreed,” Camille said. “But it would be tedious to assign authenticity to every painting with a famous name, too.”
Auguste gave a pleased grunt. “Now that is a dispute worth having.”
“It is not a dispute,” Odette said. “It is a purchase.”
“Those are often the same thing, when the price is high enough.”
Ravel examined the frame without touching it. “May I see the reverse?”
“Certainly,” Odette said. “Though I would rather not have the work removed in front of guests.”
“Then we shall not remove it in front of guests.”
“Excellent. A sensible conclusion.”
“Not a conclusion,” he said. “A postponement.”
Odette’s smile became a little brighter. “You do make everything sound so alarming, Monsieur Ravel.”
“Only when it is.”
Auguste looked between them. “Can the painting be verified before the Exposition?”
“Yes,” Ravel said. “The loan and catalogue records can be checked. Material examination can be arranged. The Exposition’s public demonstrations will provide a suitable setting if a disputed work requires witnesses.”
“Three weeks,” Camille said. “That is enough time to check a great deal.”
“More than enough,” Odette replied. “The records are straightforward.”
Ravel’s gaze shifted to her. “Then the records should settle the question.”
“They will,” Odette said.
Auguste tapped the amber head of his walking stick on the floor. “There. A timetable and a destination. We settle the matter before the sale, and the Exposition gets its jewel.”
Camille looked at the painting. The counterfeit’s pale river shone under the lamps. Three weeks gave them time. It also gave Odette time to sell it, move it, or make sure nobody ever saw it again.
Ravel shut his notebook. “The museum’s records are not mine alone to release. I will speak with Henri Lavoisier about the proper procedure.”
“Of course,” Odette said. “We should all respect procedure.”
Camille heard the warning tucked into the phrase. Odette was not asking what Camille knew. She was reminding her what could happen if she said too much.
Auguste turned toward the other guests. “Champagne, then. We have reached the first station.”
The little crowd broke into conversation. A servant passed with a tray, and Ravel took a glass he did not drink.
Camille watched him watch the painting.
“You’re actually going to check,” she said.
“I said I would.”
“Registrars say many things.”
“And artists say few of them plainly.”
“Perhaps you should try asking better questions.”
“Perhaps you should try answering one.”
She nearly smiled. “You are very determined to have my explanation.”
“You touched a painting at a sale and warned its buyer against trusting it. I would like to know whether you have a reason.”
“I do.”
“Will you tell me?”
“No.”
“Then I cannot help you.”
“You’re already helping. You noticed the nail.”
“That is a detail. I need more than a detail.”
“So do I.”
His expression softened into something like consideration, though the rest of him stayed formally still. “What would you need?”
“Access to the work. A look at the back, under proper light. And enough time before the sale for the truth to become inconvenient.”
“Those are not all things I can grant.”
“Then you are not as useful as your pencil suggests.”
“I can request an examination.”
“Request it quickly.”
“Why?”
“Because the painting is already advertised.”
Ravel looked toward the placard beneath the frame. The bold lettering made the sale sound settled, the title unquestioned. “An advertisement is not a completed transaction.”
“It is a promise in public. People tend to defend those.”
“Then the promise must be tested in public.”
For the first time, Camille found herself curious about him. Not trustful. Curiosity was cheaper.
“And if it is false?” she asked.
“Then we stop the sale.”
The answer was too quick to be mere courtesy.
“Even if the buyer is Montferrand?”
“Especially then.”
“Even if the gallery protests?”
“Protest is not evidence.”
“Even if your superiors would rather not have a scandal?”
“Those are two separate questions.”
“Convenient again.”
“On that, we agree.”
A burst of applause came from the far end of the gallery. Auguste had raised his glass and was speaking about the Exposition’s promise of industry, invention, and better connections between people who might otherwise never meet. Guests laughed at his last line.
Camille barely heard it. The counterfeit was no longer a private object or a mistake that could be quietly corrected. It had a buyer, a title, a date, and an audience waiting to admire it. If she let the sale go forward, the false Monet would leave the gallery with the weight of a public verdict behind it.
“You said we would stop it,” she said.
“If the evidence requires it.”
“Evidence is a patient creature.”
“Then we will have to be quicker.”
She studied him, looking for the neat little retreat a registrar might take when the room grew difficult. He did not offer one.
“Do not mistake this for partnership,” she said.
“I have not.”
“You are standing beside me.”
“I am standing beside the painting.”
“Of course you are.”
His mouth tilted, almost a smile and not quite. “If you have relevant knowledge, now would be the time.”
“Not here.”
“Then where?”
“Somewhere the walls do not belong to Odette.”
His eyes moved to the gallery owner. “You believe she is involved?”
“I believe she is standing next to the painting.”
“That is not evidence.”
“No,” Camille said. “It’s a reason to be careful.”
Ravel considered that. “Come to the museum tomorrow. Bring whatever you are willing to tell me.”
“Tomorrow is not enough time.”
“It is what I can arrange tonight.”
“Then arrange more.”
“I cannot promise that.”
“Good. Promises have been getting expensive.”
Across the gallery, Odette had left Auguste and was speaking with two guests. Her violet gloves rested neatly around her glass. She watched Camille over the rim, smiling as if she had just heard a charming joke.
Camille followed her gaze. Above the painting, beside the entrance, a printed notice announced the coming Exposition sale in three weeks. The counterfeit Monet’s name stood in the largest type.
The sale was already advertised.
Chapter 2
Odette’s smile held until the last guest had gone.
Then she set down her glass. “Mr. Ravel, you have promised to stop a sale on the strength of a nail and a woman’s dislike of water.”
“I said we would stop it if the evidence requires it.”
“An elegant distinction. I hope it survives the morning.”
Camille had not moved from the entrance. Rain darkened the shoulders of her green jacket, and her ink-stained fingers curled around a pair of gloves. “You are welcome to inspect the nail yourself.”
“I have no wish to handle the frame,” Odette said. “It is insured.”
“Then the insurance may inspect it.”
Auguste gave a booming laugh, then caught the chill in the room and let it die. “I have a train to catch, and a purchase to make in three weeks. I should prefer not to buy a railway timetable in place of a painting.”
“Your confidence is touching,” Odette said. “The painting has been examined by people far more experienced than either of us.”
“And yet nobody has turned it over,” Camille said.
Odette’s violet gloves came together, palm to palm. “Mr. Ravel will consult the museum. You will have your answer in due course.”
“Tomorrow,” Ravel said.
“Tomorrow,” Odette agreed. “And then we may all return to more useful business.”
Auguste offered Camille a formal nod. “Madame Duret, if this is a misunderstanding, I trust you will say so.”
“If it is, I will be delighted to be wrong.”
“That is a rare pleasure.”
“It has not been offered to me often.”
He accepted this as a joke, though it was not quite one. Odette accompanied him to the door, where her farewell was warm enough to make the nearby guests forget the chill in the gallery.
Ravel waited until the last carriage had taken them away.
“You have until tomorrow,” he said.
“I heard.”
“You have not told me what you know.”
“I told you what I can say here.”
“Then say nothing here.”
“An excellent start.”
The gallery lamps hissed above them. Camille put on her gloves. She did not offer another explanation, and Ravel had none to compel her with.
He left by the side entrance, carrying no evidence beyond the bright brass nail and a promise he had not made.
At the museum, Henri Lavoisier was still at his desk, a ledger open beside a cup of coffee gone cold. His polished boots were crossed beneath the table. A clerk had left a stack of loose papers near the lamp, and Henri had arranged them into a square.
“You are late,” Henri said.
“I was at Varenne’s gallery.”
“That explains the hour, not the expression.”
Ravel took off his hat. “The painting advertised as a Monet. Morning on the Seine.”
“Ah. The railroad gentleman’s prize.”
“Auguste Montferrand intends to buy it at the Exposition.”
Henri turned a page. “Then I hope it is a Monet.”
“So do I.”
“Your hope sounds qualified.”
“The title and dimensions are not in our catalogue.”
Henri stopped sorting the papers. “You checked?”
“I checked the current catalogue. Then the old index.”
“And?”
“Nothing matching.”
Henri closed the ledger. “That does not establish fraud.”
“No. It establishes that we cannot verify the claim from our records.”
“A distinction the ministry will appreciate.”
“Will the gallery?”
“Odette Varenne appreciates distinctions when they benefit her.”
Ravel set his notes on the desk. “She says the painting has been examined by more experienced people.”
“Names?”
“None given.”
“Convenient.”
“The canvas is in a gilt frame. There is a new brass inventory nail at the lower edge. Camille Duret says it does not belong.”
Henri leaned back. “Camille Duret?”
“You know her?”
“I know the name. She has worked in restoration rooms. Also in less official rooms, if the stories are accurate.”
Ravel kept his voice even. “What stories?”
“That she can make a painting look older than its owner. A useful skill, provided one has the right owner.”
The remark was offered lightly. Ravel did not find it so. “She says she has relevant knowledge.”
“Does she say what kind?”
“No.”
“Then you have a suspicion, a nail, and a woman who will not tell you why she cares.”
“And a catalogue that has no entry for the painting.”
“A catalogue that has no entry for that title and those dimensions,” Henri corrected. “Do not make the record say more than it does.”
Ravel wrote the dimensions from memory: the gallery label had included them in the printed catalogue Odette handed to guests. Henri consulted the museum index and searched through the relevant volume. His finger moved down the columns, then returned to the top.
“Nothing,” he said.
“Could the title be different?”
“It could. Paintings arrive under private titles. A collector calls a river scene Morning; a dealer calls it Blue Water; a catalogue clerk calls it Untitled, if the clerk has had a difficult week.”
“Could the dimensions be wrong?”
“Also possible.”
“Could both be wrong?”
“Mr. Ravel, if we are to begin inventing every possible circumstance, we shall need more coffee.”
Ravel checked the catalogue shelf himself. The bindings smelled of leather and dust. He verified the date, volume, and index. No Monet with those measurements appeared. There was no legitimate museum entry matching the displayed painting’s title and dimensions.
He returned to Henri’s desk.
“Nothing,” he said.
“Then tomorrow you ask for the reverse, under proper light, and you record what you see. If the gallery refuses, we have learned something about the gallery. Not necessarily about the painting.”
“Odette has already opposed removing it in front of the guests.”
“Then ask quietly.”
“She knows I intend to speak with you.”
Henri’s manner softened by one degree. “And what did you tell her?”
“That museum records are not mine alone to release.”
“Good. They are not.”
“I also told her that if the evidence requires it, we will stop the sale.”
Henri put both hands on the ledger. “That was less good.”
“It was true.”
“Truth does not become harmless because it is accurate.”
Ravel did not answer. The gallery’s sale notice was already printed. Three weeks was enough time to sell a painting, a reputation, and perhaps the truth between them.
Henri reopened the ledger. “Private loans receive duplicate registry slips. Those are not part of the general catalogue.”
“Do you have the slips?”
“Some. The office keeps what the office can keep.”
“Would one help?”
“It might. But you have no basis to search for an unnamed private loan yet. First, establish what is in front of you.”
Ravel gathered his notes. Henri’s qualification was sound. It was also frustrating.
“Tomorrow,” Henri said. “Bring the request through the proper channel.”
“And if the painting is being sold as a Monet without support?”
“Then we will have a proper channel for that, too.”
By the time Ravel returned to the gallery, the lamps were being extinguished. He had obtained permission to examine the painting the following morning, though Odette had placed conditions on the hour and insisted the frame remain on the wall.
She had also agreed to receive Camille.
Camille stood in the small front room, still wearing her damp jacket. Odette was beside the desk, holding a sheet of paper by its corners.
“This is the artist you have been so eager to consult,” Odette said. “Miss Duret has a lively interest in the picture.”
Camille took in the paper. “You have been busy.”
“Only sorting old accounts.”
“You have brought one of mine into the gallery.”
“One of yours?” Ravel asked.
Camille’s answer did not come at once.
Odette placed the sheet on the desk. “A receipt, dated last winter. It records payment for two painted panels, one of which was represented as an original by a minor Dutch master. The buyer discovered that it was not. The police were not involved, as I recall. The matter was settled privately.”
Ravel looked at Camille. The name on the receipt was hers.
Camille did not deny it.
Odette continued, “Mr. Ravel is a man of records. He will understand that a person with a history of imitating paintings may not be the most reliable judge of one.”
“You hired me to copy a Dutch panel,” Camille said.
“I commissioned a study.”
“You paid for a copy.”
“I paid for a painting. What you called it afterward was your choice.”
“The buyer knew it was a copy.”
“Does he?” Odette asked. “Would he say so in public?”
Ravel read the receipt. Its wording was plain enough to be damaging, but not enough to establish the story Odette told. “Why show me this?”
“Because Miss Duret has been making accusations in my gallery. If she intends to repeat them, you should know who is making them.”
Camille’s voice stayed level. “She means to expose me as a forger.”
“Only if you force me to defend my business.”
“Your business needs no defense if the painting is genuine.”
Odette smiled. “You see? She cannot even leave the subject alone.”
Ravel laid the receipt down. “This has no bearing on whether the displayed painting is authentic.”
“It has bearing on her motives.”
“It may. It does not settle the question.”
Odette’s poise tightened. “You cannot keep pretending every matter belongs to the museum.”
“No. But the catalogue belongs to it, and I have no entry matching the displayed title and dimensions.”
“That catalogue is incomplete.”
“Then we will note that.”
“Note what you like. The painting remains here, and the sale remains advertised.”
Camille’s face had gone pale beneath the rain. “You said the buyer knew.”
“I said what I said.”
“And if I tell him otherwise?”
Odette’s voice became almost gentle. “Then I will tell him what you have made. I will show him this receipt. And I will explain that the woman accusing me of fraud is a practiced forger with a debt to settle.”
Ravel had expected anger from Camille. Instead, she looked at the receipt as if it were a familiar tool laid out for use against her.
“Does that suit you?” she asked Odette.
“It is not my preferred arrangement.”
“Your preferences have never been the expensive part.”
Odette moved around the desk. “You can leave this alone. Let Mr. Ravel inspect the frame. Let the museum make its little inquiries. But you will not tell Auguste Montferrand that I commissioned false work, and you will not bring your private history into my gallery again.”
Camille was silent.
Ravel could not ask her to trust him. He had no evidence for the accusation, no proof of her claim, and a receipt that might be used to ruin her. The museum’s records offered no clean answer. Yet Odette had produced the paper before the examination, and her threat had been ready-made.
Camille put on the second glove. “I will investigate.”
Odette’s smile returned. “How sensible.”
“Not for you.”
“Miss Duret—”
“I will investigate the painting. I will not discuss my past with your guests.”
“That is not a promise I can accept.”
“It is all you are getting.”
Odette turned to Ravel. “You see what you are dealing with.”
“I see a painting whose provenance and identity remain unverified.”
“You see a woman who has just admitted she will investigate.”
“I heard her.”
Camille went to the frame. She did not touch the canvas. “The nail is new. You know that.”
“Do you?”
“I know what was there before.”
Ravel noted the careful choice of words. She did not say how she knew.
“May I examine the lower edge tomorrow?” he asked.
“Under supervision,” Odette said.
“Under proper light.”
“If you insist.”
“I do.”
Odette rang for the porter. “Then the matter is settled until morning.”
Camille moved toward the door. Ravel followed, leaving Odette with the receipt and the painting.
Outside, the street was wet and bright with gaslight. Camille stopped beneath the gallery’s narrow awning.
“You will have to tell me what you know,” Ravel said.
“I told you I would investigate.”
“That is not the same thing.”
“No. It is what I can offer tonight.”
“Odette has a receipt that could damage your name.”
“She has a receipt she can make sound worse than it is.”
“Is it false?”
“No.”
The answer was simple. Ravel waited.
Camille looked toward the street. “I will give you more when I know what you are asking me to risk.”
“I am asking you to help determine whether a painting is being sold under a false name.”
“And if the answer points at me?”
“Then I will have to record what I find.”
“Precisely.”
The tram rattled past, throwing a fan of water from the rails. Camille stepped back from the curb.
Ravel said, “I will not conceal evidence.”
“Good.”
“I will not let Odette dictate what evidence means.”
“That would be a start.”
He offered to arrange a carriage. Camille refused and walked toward the boulevard, leaving the matter between them unsettled but no longer separate.
Ravel returned to the gallery the next morning with a lamp, a measuring rod, and a written request from the museum. Odette permitted the inspection in the presence of a porter. Camille arrived without her jacket, carrying a small notebook.
The frame remained on the wall. Ravel measured the visible canvas and compared it with the catalogue dimensions printed on the sale notice. The difference was small, but real.
“Your notice gives the wrong width,” he said.
“By less than a finger,” Odette replied.
“A catalogue is not improved by approximation.”
“Nor is a painting proved false by a finger.”
Camille wrote down the measurement. “The frame is wider than the canvas.”
“That proves the frame was made for the canvas,” Odette said.
“It proves someone selected a frame,” Ravel replied.
He trained the lamp along the lower edge. The bright nail’s head caught the light. It sat at an angle that differed from the older fittings. He did not remove it.
“Was this frame recently repaired?” he asked.
“Not to my knowledge.”
“Who installed the nail?”
“I cannot recall.”
Camille’s pencil stopped.
Ravel examined the back through the gap between frame and wall. The stretcher wood was clean, nearly free of dust and age-darkening. Its corners were crisp. Even the canvas edges showed little discoloration.
He leaned closer, careful not to touch it.
“The stretcher is unusually clean,” he said.
“New wood is not a crime,” Odette replied.
“No. It is a fact.”
Camille closed her notebook. “And the nail?”
“A fact, too.”
“Nothing more?”
“Not yet.”
The clean stretcher could belong to a recent re-stretching. The nail could have secured the canvas after a repair. Taken separately, neither established substitution. Together, they required an explanation.
Ravel asked the porter to bring a stand so the frame could be lifted from its hook without being turned over. Odette refused permission to remove it from the wall. She would allow no more than the inspection already made.
The refusal left Ravel with a measurement, a clean stretcher, and a nail that looked newly driven. The answer would not come from guessing.
In the gallery office, a telegram arrived before noon. Odette read it first, then handed it to Ravel.
It announced that the painting, described as the Monet, would be unveiled beneath the Eiffel Tower.
Chapter 3
Ravel folded the telegram along its existing crease.
“Beneath the tower,” he said. “With an audience.”
Odette slipped the message from his hand. “Monsieur Montferrand prefers a memorable setting.”
“Does he know the painting has no museum entry matching its description?”
“He knows what I have told him.”
“That is not the same thing.”
“From a dealer, it is usually more useful.”
Camille had heard enough. The telegram changed the timetable. Odette would not leave the painting in the gallery while a registrar asked careful questions. She would put it beneath the Eiffel Tower, summon witnesses, and make a sale look like a public honor.
Ravel turned to the gallery porter. “I need access to the museum catalogue.”
“You have access,” Odette said. “To the gallery office.”
“The museum catalogue is not in the gallery office.”
“How unfortunate for your investigation.”
“Odette,” Camille said, “if the painting is genuine, a search will settle the matter.”
“And if it is not?”
“Then a search will settle that, too.”
Odette’s smile stayed polished. “You are both welcome to settle whatever you like. You will not remove the picture from this wall.”
“No one has asked to,” Ravel said.
“Yet.”
Camille kept her notebook shut. The scratch of her pencil would only give Odette something to watch. “We need the loan records as well as the catalogue.”
“Need is an ambitious word,” Odette said.
“Then call it a preference.”
The gallery owner adjusted one violet glove. “You have until this afternoon. The painting goes to the Exposition office tonight.”
Ravel tucked the telegram into his coat. “That is not enough time.”
“Then work quickly.”
Odette returned to her customers, leaving the two investigators beside the office door. The porter waited for instructions. Ravel gave none until Camille had crossed into the corridor.
“You can have the catalogue,” she said quietly. “You cannot have the painting.”
“I gathered that.”
“Good. I dislike repeating myself.”
“I had thought you enjoyed it.”
“That depends on the audience.”
He took out his catalogue pencil and wrote something in the margin of his notebook. “The museum will have the loan register. If Lavoisier is there, he may permit us to consult it.”
“May?”
“He worries about the ministry.”
“Then let us be reassuring.”
“You have a peculiar definition of reassuring.”
Camille led the way out. The porter called after them to sign the visitor book. Ravel did so, using his full title. Camille signed as a gallery inspector.
“Are you?” he asked.
“I have inspected the gallery.”
“That is one interpretation.”
“It is the only one that matters to a visitor book.”
They walked the few blocks to the museum in the morning’s press of carriages and pedestrians. Camille kept their pace brisk. Ravel carried the telegram and his notes, while she rehearsed the simplest account of their purpose: two inspectors at odds over a disputed painting, seeking catalogue entries before a public unveiling.
They would need to quarrel convincingly. That part should not be difficult.
At the museum, Henri Lavoisier received them in a narrow office crowded with ledgers. His polished boots stood neatly beneath his desk; a ledger lay open beside his elbow. He listened to Ravel’s account, then inspected the telegram.
“An unveiling beneath the Eiffel Tower,” Henri said. “There will be press.”
“That is the attraction,” Ravel replied.
“It is also the complication.” Henri closed the ledger. “A public suggestion that a patron has bought a false painting could reach the ministry before we have established anything.”
“Which is why we are asking for records,” Camille said.
Henri glanced over the top of the ledger. “And you are?”
“Camille Duret. I inspect pictures for galleries.”
“Not for museums.”
“Not yet.”
Ravel gave her a restrained look of disapproval that was almost convincing. Camille answered with a level, impatient stare.
“Could we have the catalogue?” she asked. “Or must I get Ravel’s permission?”
Henri’s mouth twitched. “You have already decided to quarrel.”
“We have decided it will be useful.”
“I am not sure that is reassuring.”
“It was not meant to be.”
Ravel set the telegram on Henri’s desk. “The painting is described as a Monet. Its dimensions are known. No matching entry has been found in the museum catalogue.”
“Then the catalogue may be incomplete,” Henri said.
“Or the description may be false.”
“Or the work is recorded under a different title.”
“That is why we need the loan records.”
Henri rested one hand on the ledger. “The loan register is not a public entertainment.”
“Neither is the Eiffel Tower,” Camille said. “Yet someone intends to turn a painting into one.”
“Miss Duret,” Ravel said, “if you would allow me to make the request?”
“You may make it. I’m only correcting the scenery.”
Henri looked from one to the other. “If I give you access, I will need a clear account of what you are examining and why.”
“You shall have it in writing,” Ravel said.
“And I must be able to state that the museum has made no judgment on the painting’s authenticity.”
“Agreed.”
“Nor on the conduct of its owner.”
“Agreed.”
Henri took a fresh sheet of paper and began drafting the terms. His careful qualifications filled half the page. Ravel read them, made one small correction, and signed. Camille signed beneath him.
When Henri handed the paper back, he added, “You may consult the Exposition loan records for forty-eight hours. The registers stay here. No pages leave the archive, and no marks are to be made in them.”
Ravel folded the authorization. “Thank you.”
“Do not thank me yet. If the ministry asks why I permitted this, I will say I was trying to prevent two inspectors from quarreling in a public gallery.”
“That will be accurate,” Camille said.
“Accuracy has its uses.”
Henri led them through a staff corridor to the catalogue room. The room held shelves of bound records, arranged by year and category. A clerk brought them the catalogue volumes for Monet and the loan registers for the current Exposition.
Ravel opened the first catalogue. Camille took the volume beside it, and they began checking entries.
They kept up their quarrel.
“Your dimensions are wrong,” Camille said.
“They are the dimensions reported in the gallery’s own record.”
“Then the gallery’s record is wrong.”
“Or your measurement is.”
“Do you always defend a measurement before making one?”
“Only when the alternative is your arithmetic.”
Henri sat at a nearby desk, trying to work. The clerk had gone back to the outer office. Their voices carried just enough to make the performance useful, not enough to make it disruptive.
Camille turned a page. She read each entry aloud, then checked it against Ravel’s notes. The Monet listings covered landscapes, rivers, gardens, stations. The titles varied, some in French, some translated from earlier catalogues. The dimensions did not match the painting in Odette’s gallery.
They checked loans from private collections. They searched under the artist’s name, then under places and subjects. Camille tried the river towns, the bridges, the gardens.
Nothing.
Ravel made another note. “The gallery’s description may use a title invented for the sale.”
“Then we search the subject.”
“We have.”
“Not all of them.”
“Miss Duret—”
“Tell me, Monsieur Ravel, do you catalogue paintings by the names they carry or the names you wish they had?”
Henri’s quill paused.
Ravel closed his book with a deliberate snap. “I catalogue what is recorded. I cannot help it if a gallery chooses a convenient title.”
“Convenient for whom?”
“Your guess is as good as mine.”
Camille turned away to the loan register. She had to keep the counterfeit’s surface in mind without letting it take over the search. What had she seen at the gallery? The fresh stretcher. The slanted nail. And, in the shadow under the frame, a small stroke of blue where the paint had reached the edge.
The blue had been too vivid for the landscape around it. A cobalt note, clean and cool. She had seen the pigment before, though not in the Monet works she knew.
She did not mention that to Ravel. It was a detail, not a conclusion. In a gallery, a single pigment could be a restoration, a later touch, or a painter’s mistake. It could also be a clue.
“Try the Exposition loans by subject,” she said.
Ravel turned a page. “The current register is organized by donor, not subject.”
“Then start with the anonymous entries.”
“Why?”
“Because the title may not be the one we were given.”
He scanned the register. “There are six anonymous loans.”
“Five, if one is a group of prints.”
“Four, then.”
“Three. That line says ‘studies.’”
“Two.”
Camille came to stand beside him. Their sleeves nearly touched over the page.
He pointed with the catalogue pencil. “This one is a landscape, anonymous, dimensions not listed.”
“Not it.”
“The next is a river scene.”
She read the entry. The line had been written in a different hand, with a short description and a number indicating that further information was filed elsewhere.
“Could be anything,” Ravel said.
“Could be the only lead we have.”
“Then we need the supplementary entry.”
Henri had risen from his desk. “The cross-reference is in the supplemental volume. I can retrieve it.”
“Please,” Ravel said.
Henri went to the shelves. Camille kept her finger beside the line without touching the paper. The original title had not appeared in the main catalogue. That did not prove the painting was there. It did give them something more substantial than a missing entry to pursue.
Henri returned with another volume and opened it on the table. He found the number. Beside it, a brief note referred to a private loan and a separate descriptive card.
“Here,” he said. “Anonymous river scene. The card is filed with the Exposition documentation.”
Camille leaned over the open ledger. The description included the same dimensions Ravel had measured in Odette’s gallery.
Ravel copied the reference number into his notebook.
Henri shut the volume. “The card is held with the Exposition office papers. I cannot promise what it will show.”
“It shows there was another title,” Camille said.
“It shows an entry exists,” Henri replied. “Nothing more.”
“Still more than we had this morning.”
Ravel slid his notebook into his coat. “We should see the card.”
“Not today,” Henri said. “You have access to the registers for forty-eight hours, not to every file in the building.”
“Then we will request the card through the proper office.”
“Do so. I will note the request.”
Create a free account to read all remaining chapters.
Free plan · No credit card required.
Share this story
More stories from the community
Browse Discover →Want your own personalized story?
Start writing for free →Monthly story picks · New features · Writing inspiration, straight to your inbox
No spam, unsubscribe anytime